15
AUTHOR'S SCORE

Director Olivier Assayas, known for films like Irma Vep (1996), Summer Hours (2008), and Non-Fiction (2018), now presents The Wizard of the Kremlin. The film, which had its world premiere at the 82nd Venice International Film Festival, is adapted from the novel of the same name by Italian writer Giuliano da Empoli. Assayas co-wrote the screenplay with Emmanuel Carrère, and the cast includes Paul Dano, Jeffrey Wright, Jude Law, and Alicia Vikander.

15
AUTHOR'S SCORE

Russia, one of the civilizations that has governed the world for centuries, is undoubtedly one of the permanent decision-makers. The “Russian identity,” rooted in the ninth century and fed by more than a millennium of different state structures, has similarly been addressed by hundreds of thousands of literary sources. Today we encounter countless works dealing specifically with the period stretching from the collapse of the Soviet Union to modern Russia. Giuliano da Empoli‘s novel is one of those written within this framework. The novel has a remarkably broad spectrum, focusing on the behind-the-scenes manipulations of modern Russia, the rise of a dictator, and the question of “raison d’état.” Consequently, adapting a work rooted in such a deep chronology to the screen is a deeply challenging endeavor. While looking at the transformations of a civilization through what we cannot see is intriguing, the sheer scope of the ambition is ultimately a very bold desire. What happens to Assayas here is unfortunately getting lost in the ideological motivation of this ambitious desire. The Wizard of the Kremlin is a production that drowns in the dozens of events and points it tries to cover, yet cannot realize it is sinking to the bottom.

The Wizard of Kremlin Film Review Arakat Mag Olivier Assayas Paul Dano Alicia Vikander 45th Istanbul Film Festival

The Difficulty of Dominion

Assayas tries to approach this difficult text not only through Putin’s rise but also through the manipulation of the masses. Through the fictional character of Vadim Baranov, we first focus on Russia’s political machinery of the 1990s. At this point, the character is a fictional representation of Vladislav Surkov, widely regarded as Vladimir Putin’s right hand. The film divides its story into certain episodic sections.

We witness a historical scale stretching from the Second Chechen War to the Sochi Winter Olympics. Along with Baranov’s career arc from theater director to political advisor, we gain access to the backstage of Russia. American academic Rowland visits Baranov for a research project — effectively taking the place of the novelist Giuliano da Empoli. The conversation between the two drags us into the middle of Russia’s most significant turning points.

The biggest problem with The Wizard of the Kremlin is its inability to decide where to approach the issues it deals with. Beyond the difficult story it attempts to examine, the film makes no effort to master this vast territory. Sometimes it approaches a topic with a documentary sensibility, and at other times it tries to deepen a sequence that has no real importance to the narrative’s progression. It plans all its scenes not to deepen its characters but merely to create “moments.” Going far beyond the typical period film error, it eliminates the connections between sequences. Because it tries to build the entire story around Baranov’s rise alongside Putin. But it skips over the background of this development. In such a wide spectrum, it is nearly impossible for all figures to be developed. Yet here we witness a rise story in which we barely come to know even the main character. As a result, seeing how the characters develop becomes quite difficult. We generally understand the changes that have occurred only when we notice Baranov in different positions. The enormity of the subject causes the lens to be unable to decide where to zoom in and where to look away.

The Wizard of Kremlin Film Review Arakat Mag Olivier Assayas Paul Dano Alicia Vikander 45th Istanbul Film Festival

Depth and Distance

The Wizard of Kremlin, along with its considerable length, contains no formal effectiveness and no distinctive narrative form. The screenplay repeats most issues multiple times with the same perspective and similar setups. We witness a screenplay in which we can predict how scenes about the behind-the-scenes manipulations of Russia will end. Yet the concept of manipulation is one of the greatest defense mechanisms of all regimes, especially authoritarian ones. So there is great potential in the narrative, exploitable in every sense. Yet the moments we see in the story can barely approach the philosophical and questioning dimension of the issue.

Within these chronological stories, the conversations between Baranov and Rowland not only add nothing but actually drag the narrative’s tempo downward. They contain an interaction that only creates enthusiasm for Assayas. The cold and distant character of Baranov as played by Paul Dano remains too distant in every sense. Even in the scene near the film’s opening that focuses on nightlife — where all the factors are present on screen — nothing looks like it belongs to that era. Even the appearance of Paul Dano’s character… This difficult text can only achieve a fluent quality at certain points in terms of editing. Beyond that, most remaining elements, including the performances, sit at or below standard.

We mentioned earlier the narrative’s inability to decide what to approach and what to avoid. To this problem is added, at certain moments, the issue of approaching the topic in question in academic and terminological language. This problem is also created by the text’s general imbalance. A work packed with limited explanations and superficial dialogues can suddenly shift direction toward deep political exposition. Or, conversely, it can pass over an important scene where we expect explanation with a simpler treatment.

In one scene, Baranov speaks of Russia’s journey from the horizontal politics of the Yeltsin era — a controlled chaos — to the vertical authority it achieved under Putin. He similarly articulates the nostalgia for Stalin. He describes the oligarchs planning to govern the state as a side factor creating problems for the construction of this vertical power. Elements like these are actually the primary factors that could increase the film’s depth. But the fundamental problem here lies in being swept away by the wind of the chronological scale that is difficult to master. As everything progresses as confusingly as possible, these details suddenly rush out of the characters’ mouths. That is why they remain nothing more than hollow aphorisms. When the narrative should deepen certain elements by having them spoken, it chooses to stage the parts that should be conveyed by the narrator.

The Wizard of Kremlin Film Review Arakat Mag Olivier Assayas Paul Dano Alicia Vikander 45th Istanbul Film Festival

Under the Western Gaze

In a production made up of such important Hollywood figures, it is worth touching on the Western perspective. When the subject is a Russian narrative from an American point of view, several examples undoubtedly come to mind. The Wizard of the Kremlin is the newest addition to that list. The story’s choice of the English language is perhaps the last thing to mention here — a clichéd point of contention. Especially given that Jude Law plays his role with a sharp British accent. There is a well-worn audacity here of the West telling the story of a different geography through its own cultural codes. The film offers no approach that departs from the usual American point of view.

The narrative is less concerned with telling Russia’s political history than with focusing on how characters behave bureaucratically and coldly. Noteworthy in this context is the fact that it focuses on Putin’s charisma or his room without deepening important turning points. Contained within it is a Putin perspective designed as a response to the Cold War-era secret admiration for Russia. One of the biggest criteria of this Western gaze is that at no point in the film do we feel like we are inside a part of Russia. Shot in Latvia, the film tries to convey everything through an atmosphere that is as “gray” and overcast as possible. It follows Russia through characters who roam in fur coats and frequently consume alcohol. When we move away from the bureaucratic sphere, these are the only elements that greet us. In a work touching on important periods of Russian history, we never try to understand that country in any sociological or psychological framework — even though the motivations of the bureaucratic characters being examined are mostly connected to these two social sciences. We watch characters who look bureaucratic against cold cardboard plans, without touching on any of the era’s pains or, conversely, its sociocultural problems.

The Wizard of the Kremlin is so devoid of design that it cannot capture any angle of a boundless era even within its long running time of two and a half hours. Assayas‘s perspective is limited to simply re-reading the original text.


To read more articles by Ahmet Duvan, click here.

Follow us on Youtube, X and Instagram for more.

Hen: A Wandering Vagrant

Late Fame: The Fear of Dying Undiscovered

Ahmet Duvan

Hen: A Wandering Vagrant

önceki yazı

Undertone: The Black Hole in Your Headphones

sonraki yazı

Yorumlar

Yorumlar kapatıldı.

Bunlar da ilginizi çekebilir

daha fazla FILM REVIEWS